NFLPA wants to restrict media access to NFL locker rooms, citing privacy
Two seasons after the NFL reopened teams’ locker rooms to reporters following the coronavirus pandemic, player leaders would like to modify locker-room access for privacy reasons. NFL Players Association officials say they are attempting to have the league’s policies adjusted to have reporters interview players in a different setting following games and during practice weeks.
“What I was hoping to achieve on behalf of the membership is … to accurately articulate how they feel,” Lloyd Howell, the NFLPA’s executive director, said during a meeting this week with Washington Post reporters and editors. “And they do not want to be interviewed when they’re naked — [and] to open the door for doing some solutioning of what could be more effective.”
The union has had discussions on the issue with the league and with the Pro Football Writers of America. Howell said the NFLPA is not attempting to keep reporters from doing their jobs or to reduce the amount of time during which players would be available to media members.
Advertisement
“I’ve heard and I’ve seen all the reasons why the media is hesitant or resistant to changing it: [Players] duck out of the back. They don’t want to do the interview. The list goes on and on,” Howell said. “But there are other ways to kind of address those challenges, too. … The desire isn’t in any way to prevent [reporters from having access to players]. The desire is, ‘Let me be decent.’”
It’s not clear whether the NFLPA will succeed or what the timing for any changes would be. A modification for the upcoming season seems unlikely, given that the NFL’s 2024 media policy already has been set and distributed. And while the league has expressed a willingness to listen to the players’ privacy concerns, it has not signaled an intention to make a change. The NFL declined to comment.
The NFL continued to operate during the pandemic but, like other professional sports leagues, closed its locker rooms to reporters as part of its strict health protocols. Those protocols were formulated jointly by the NFL and the NFLPA for the 2020 and 2021 seasons, giving the union a say in media access during that period. Reporters conducted interviews virtually or, later, in news conferences or group settings outside the locker room. The league did allow some team-affiliated reporters into locker rooms during the 2021 season.
Advertisement
The NFL dropped its coronavirus protocols entirely and reopened locker rooms to accredited media members in advance of the 2022 season. For the past two seasons, reporters have had access to players in locker rooms following games and at teams’ practice facilities during the week. But the NFLPA has raised privacy concerns.
“We want to respect the players’ privacy to get dressed,” Calvin Watkins, a reporter for the Dallas Morning News who is the PFWA’s president, said by phone Thursday. “I don’t think any reporter wants to talk to a butt-naked player. However, there are already rules in place for the player to have privacy before doing the interview. We have reiterated that to the union.”
The current NFL media policy says player privacy in the locker room “is of paramount importance.” It calls for the shower area to be “screened from view” and says teams must supply players with “wraparound towels” or robes. Teams are “urged to take other measures,” such as placing a pair of shorts in each player’s locker or building individual locker curtains. A team communications staffer is to inform players and coaches when the locker room is about to be opened.
Advertisement
The policy calls for players to be available to reporters after games and four times during a normal practice week, with open locker rooms for at least 45 minutes on each Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.
Reporters say being allowed in locker rooms is necessary for media members who cover teams regularly so they can ask questions in non-group settings while developing relationships with players and building sources.
“We have a tremendous amount of respect for the players, and we want to make sure they are comfortable doing interviews,” Watkins said. “However, we have a job to do, and that’s to be in the locker room. I really like Lloyd. I really believe he wants what’s in the best interests of everyone involved. And hopefully down the line, this issue will not be an issue.”
The PFWA informed its members recently that the union suggested having players and media members interact in a designated mixed zone outside the locker room, similar to the system used in international soccer and at the Olympics. There also were discussions about extending the waiting period after games (currently 10 to 15 minutes) before locker rooms are opened to the media.
Howell said this week that the differing views are “to be expected” because of the current guidelines.
Advertisement
“It’s a challenge to the model where the model is ‘I want to be in the dressing room with individuals that are in varying degrees of undress with a microphone and a camera because I’m going to be able to do my job most effectively,’” Howell said. “And where the players are is: ‘I definitely want to engage with the media, but I’d like to have the opportunity to be decent. I’d like to be dressed. I’d like to, you know, get my thoughts together and then conduct the interview.’”
Howell said he could give reporters more access with a revised model, adding, “But we’re holding on to artifacts of what happened a long time ago and trying to carry it forward.”
The NFLPA raised its privacy concerns to the NFL in January, according to a person familiar with the discussions. NFL representatives rejected the union’s request then to close teams’ locker rooms to media members, according to that person. The sides left open the possibility of resuming that dialogue at some point, but there have been no further discussions, the person said.
Advertisement
Howell said the existing media policy allows for reporters’ interviews with players to be conducted outside the locker room and “that could be an outcome.” But the NFLPA will continue to seek a broader solution, he said.
“Beyond saying, ‘Hey, this is an issue to us,’ [the players] want to be part of some solutioning that, you know, is a win-win, where they will do the interview, where [reporters] will have access,” Howell said. “But at the same time, ‘Respect my space.’ … That’s really it. And I’m hopeful that we’ll make progress.”
ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7uK3SoaCnn6Sku7G70q1lnKedZMCxu9GtqmhqYGeBcHyWaGlvZ56buW65xJ2gmmWiqrmmv4ylppyjlad6s7vOpmSam5OawLR7